It is very important to understand your
enemy. Though you may not be able to beat them, knowing their
strength and qualities helps us to have confidence. We are already
experts at expressing negative emotion; we don't need to work
on that. The seventh Dalai Lama and the Kadampa Masters have
advised us to notice what factors give rise to what emotions,
and to become experts in this sense. We tend to have an attraction
to anything we associate with ourselves, and repulsion for things
associated with others. Nagarjuna once noted "to a mind
that clings, why wouldn't afflictions arise?" Underlying
emotion is the assumption that things exist independently. A
belief in independent reality leads to a powerful emotional relationship
with that reality. The quality of knowing is endless and beginningless.
Is ignorance the same way? No -- powerful emotions are not in
the mind at all times. In principle, they are separable from
mind. Fundamental ignorance can be taken away, countered, as
insight grows in power.
If we think there's no end to suffering,
no possibility of freedom, this will lead us to desperation and
even suicide. Some may think it's healthier to avoid contemplation
of suffering. But when you appreciate that there is a possibility
for release, this contemplation becomes a positive endeavor.
The path of truth must be understood through experience. Imprints
subtly obstruct full perfection. Within a single experience,
we usually don't have direct realization but perceive only emptiness
or conventional reality. We don't perceive both of these at once,
or the unity of samsara and nirvana. Even wisdom realizing emptiness
motivated by a desire to attain liberation is not enough -- we
must be motivated by altruism. Our karmic accumulation must also
be right. This is quite an amazing aspiration. There is no guarantee
that faith alone in the dharma is firm. It needs to be grounded
in understanding, which can only be gained after having a basic
grasp of the whole path.
Questions from the audience, answered
by H.H. The Dalai Lama:
1. How can we teach kids
about afflictive emotions?
HHDL: You must relate the teachings
to kids' own personal experience. Ask a child to remember if
anger is a good or an unpleasant feeling, whether an angry family
is happy. Not in order to judge but in order to understand. In
school, kids already have some experience of ignorance and knowledge.
2. You advised us not to be skeptical
but to have a reasonable doubt. To what degree should we doubt,
then?
HHDL: This is an issue of language confusion.
My advice was not to be an extreme skeptic. Generally, Buddhists
do need some doubt. This is needed for applying critical reasoning
to the Buddha's teachings, and for distinguishing between provisional
and definitive teachings. We must determine experientially which
is which. A hardened and self-righteous skepticism is what we
must avoid.
3. How can we skillfully attack delusion
without self-hatred?
HHDL: Even attacking delusion suggests
caring for oneself. The goal is to rid yourself of unhappiness.
One must differentiate the person from the act or motives. One
must develop compassion, because that person is under the control
of negative emotions. One must acknowledge the negativity, but
know that we are not equivalent to that negative state of mind.
4. What can we do to prevent suicide?
HHDL: Even suicide is ultimately pointless
in a Buddhist context! As I understand self-hatred, it arises
out of an attachment to self and expectations of the self. This
leads to self-judging. We must recognize the possibility of a
better day.
Days Five and Six: A discussion of the proper order of meditations
by His Holiness The Dalai Lama Suffering of change. We must understand
the suffering of pervasive conditioning. We can imagine ourselves
undergoing all sufferings, and then shift our focus to others
to develop compassion. We must meditate on death for a sense
of urgency, and in order to let go of attachments to immediate
events and conditions. We also should have the right sequence
of meditations. Consideration for others' welfare leads to nirvana
for all. What is perfect enlightenment? It is impossible to judge
the appropriateness of a teaching without being enlightened oneself.
We should first be perfectly enlightened. One's own self-interest
is served as a by-product of aspiring to Bodhicitta.
One needs to level feelings towards family
and friends as well as towards enemies. In order to do this,
you can visualize three individuals: one neutral, one friend,
and one enemy. Allow normal reactions to these people to arise.
Then, try to cultivate equanimity toward them -- the enemy was
not born as our enemy. Due to conditions he is the enemy, but
there is no absolute status to the person. Our friends as well
-- we should examine the grounds for that emotion, and realize
that later they may become our enemy. Equanimity can thus come.
Use particular individuals so that you have concrete objects
and not general ones; this is more effective. Next, take a model
of someone who has been kind to you and cultivate affection and
empathy. Then think that there isn't one person who hasn't been
kind to us at one time in our lifetimes. Meditate on the kindness
of others. All people contribute indirectly to our well being.
Even on the path to enlightenment we depend on others. Altruism
is only cultivated through meditation on others. Practice equalizing
yourself with others. Fundamentally you are equal. Reflect on
the pros and cons of self-cherishing and attachment. Cherish
others' well being. Exchange the self for others. Practice giving
and taking -- taking in others' negativity and suffering, and
giving away the body, resources, etc. in a visualization. Eventually,
learn to cultivate the Bodhicitta attitude.